This article is as much about a recording as it is about a truly great popular song. I know a lot about Strawberry Fields Forever because I wrote a dissertation comparing the psychology of this song with Penny Lane as a part of my Bachelor of Arts degree and did lots of research on the subject.
 |
| Strawberry Field, Liverpool, England |
First, some background details. In 1966 the Beatles manager, Brian Epstein, was pressing George
Martin for a new single release.
They had just begun work on a new ‘concept’ album that became Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band.
The idea behind the album was initially that they would create a retrospective
biographical look back to their home city of Liverpool. The first contributions were John Lennon’s Strawberry Fields and Paul McCartney’s Penny Lane. It was decided to
release the songs as a double A-sided single and they never appeared on the final
album. George Martin later claimed that "it was the biggest mistake of my career". Strawberry Field was a Salvation Army children’s home near
to where John Lennon lived with his Auntie Mimi.
Lyrically the song is an emblem of Lennon’s indecision and
uncertainty at the timer of writing it:
“Always, no sometimes,
think it’s me,
But you know I know when it’s
a dream.
I think er no, but I mean
er yes but it’s all wrong.
That is I think I disagree.”
Further remarkable
evidence of indecision is shown by a really innovative event in the recording
studio. Many versions of the song were recorded over several months. After Take
7 on 29th November 1966, everyone thought that Strawberry Fields Forever was
finished. Except John Lennon. After Take 26 on 21st December 1966, everyone
thought that Strawberry Fields Forever was finished. Except John Lennon. John told George
Martin “I like both versions. Why don’t we join them together?” However, there
were two MAJOR problems; the two versions were in different keys and in very
different tempos. These days that would be no problem but in the sixties the digital technology that could achieve this was decades away.
 |
| John Lennon. 1940-1980 |
The first version was in B-flat Major at 90 beats per minute and the second, a whole tone above, in C-major and at 108 beats per minutes. In those days 'splicing' literally meant using a pair of scissors and splicing tape! What to do?
John Lennon, never a
realist and not technically minded, left the problem to George Martin and recording
engineer Geoff Emerick.
I don’t believe in
miracles but what happened next was, well I would say, sensational. They had
variable speed tape-recorders at the Abbey Road studios and they found that by speeding-up
one recording and slowing down the other one they could get an exact match.
They had very fine control over the speed (and therefore the pitch) but by the
most amazing luck and ingenuity they achieved Lennon’s wish. It turned out that the differences in pitch were exactly compensated for by slowing one and speeding up the other.
When you listen to the recording
(click here) you can hear the change, just about, after 59 seconds. Listening
to the drumbeat is the easiest way to pick it out. The purpose of an edit, of course, is that it shouldn't be heard and a marvellous job had been done.
A by-product of this work
was that it gave Lennon’s voice a smokey, other-worldly sound which really
suits the song. It also left the recording in an in-between pitch not exactly in any recognised key. Although Lennon had composed it in C using a guitar the published version is written as being in B-flat. The song has an unusual structure in that it starts with a chorus followed by alternate verses and choruses and ending with a chorus which gives it a musically palindromic structure. The introduction is played on a Mellotron, a keyboard instrument that used electronic recording tape so that many different sounds could be used by pre-recording them. Some sources claimed that it was played by Lennon and others by McCartney.
FOOTNOTE: It turned out that Strawberry Field wasn't forever. The Salvation Army closed the children's home in 2005 and it was demolished in 2007. Lennon Hall now stands in it's place.